HomeMy WebLinkAbout240926 Response #2 Stormwater Peer Review - - 0 GREAT POND ROAD ENVIRONMENTAL
September 26, 2024
Ms.Jean Enright, Planning Director
North Andover Planning Board
120 Main Street
North Andover, Massachusetts 01845
. .
North Lake lal Stormwater Peer Revoiew
ichew*lck Boat Launch
North Andover,, Massachusetts
Dear Ms. Enright and Planning Board Members,
On behalf of the Town of North Andover(the Applicant), Environmental Partners Group, LLC(EP) has
prepared this letter in response to the peer review comments received from Horsley Witten Group
(HW) on September 20, 2024. A list of attachments to this letter is provided below.
Horsley Witten Group'sfinal open comments are listed below in bold followed by EP's responses in
italics.
Stormwater Management Design Peer Review
7.b:The Applicant mentions"project compliance with the performance criteria as identified
in Section 250-27". However, §250-27 relates to the O&M Plan,while §250-23 relates to
redevelopment projects.Attachment 5 provided by the Applicant(North Andover Design and
Performance Criteria with Attachments) illustrates how the project complies with Standard 2,
but it does not directly reference the stormwater requirements in §250-23. Specifically, §250-
23C provides specific requirements for redevelopment sites such as reducing total
phosphorus. HW suggests that the Applicant confirm it is complying with §250-23.
Environmental Partners referenced the 2-15-2011 version of the Stormwater Management bylaws located
on the North Andover Planning Board webpage link. In review of the updated version for redevelopment
projects, we confirm that we are complying with the redevelopment standards of 23C. The project does not
propose any new impervious areas. Therefore, the project does not propose to add TSS or total-
phosphorus post construction. The proposed bioretention areas will improve the area overall by treating
additional impervious areas of the paved right of way on Great Pond Road as an added benefit. Our
submission included treatment to show the additional TSS removal outside of our proposed project area.
8.c:The Applicant confirmed that the construction entrance on Sheet C-2 of the permit
drawings is at least 30 feet long. However, on Sheet CD-1 the construction entrance detail is
Page::'!".i')
shown as 15 feet long. HW recommends that the Applicant confirm that the plan and
construction detail are consistent.
There are no changes to the construction entrance. The construction entrance is 30 ft long as shown on
the plan set. The detail shown is a standard typical detail shown as 15"+/-.
9.a: In accordance with §250-27 A.An operation and maintenance plan (O&M Plan)for the
permanent stormwater management system is required at the time of application for all
projects that include the structural and nonstructural stormwater BMPs.The Applicant has
provided a BMP location map and O&M Plan for the Bioretention Areas only. However, an
O&M Plan is required for all structural and nonstructural stormwater BMPs, which includes
permeable pavers, riprap aprons, and the lined swale. HW recommends that the Applicant
provide the O&M Plan for long term functionality of the proposed stormwater system.
Please find attached the updated 0&M plan including pavers and rip-rap.
9.b"the Long-Term Operation and Maintenance Plan shall at a minimum include: ... 3.The
routine and non-routine maintenance tasks to be undertaken after construction is complete
and a schedule for implementing those tasks; ... 6.An estimated operations and maintenance
budget". HW recommends that the Applicant include the information noted above to confirm
the Town fully understands what is expected for long term maintenance.
Please find attached the updated O&M plan.
Sincerely,
Environmental Partners Group, LLC
Ryan J. Paul, PE, CFM
Senior Project Manager
O: 617.657.0260
E: rjp@envpartners.com
Attachments:
1. Revised O&M Plan
n v I a IIrt ri e SmC 0 II
ENVIRONMENTAL
VM PARTNERS
OPERATIO N A ND M AINTENA N CE P LAN
NORTH LAKE C 0 C C E1W C K BOAT LAUNCH
TOWN GF NORTH ANDOVER
i o et e:nt i o n Are a s
Premature failure of bioretention areas is a significant issue caused by lack of regular maintenance.
Ensuring long-term maintenance involves sustained public education and deed restrictions or
covenants for privately owned cells. Bioretention areas require careful attention while plants are
being established and seasonal landscaping maintenance thereafter.Table 1 shows the bioretention
maintenance schedule below.
�uiif o Oua i�u� u�li�o uim i i�i of luoi i�o�om o�i oii mi i i m - �
s m
oio o Ima o Oo '... . ii ii�i of li mi o
Activity Time of Year Frequency
Inspect and remove trash Year round Monthly
Mulch Spring Annually
Replace dead vegetation' Spring Annually
Prune Spring or Fall Annually
Replace entire media and all Late Spring/early Summer As needed
vegetation
1. See Planting List in Drawing Plans
2. Paying careful attention to operation and maintenance can extend the life of the soil media.
Inspect soil and repair eroded areas monthly. Re-mulch void areas as needed. Remove litter and
debris monthly. Treat diseased vegetation as needed. Remove and replace dead vegetation twice
per year(spring and fall).
Remove invasive species as needed to prevent these species from spreading into the bioretention
area. Replace mulch every two years, in the early spring. Upon failure, excavate bioretention area,
scarify bottom and sides, replace filter fabric and soil, replant, and mulch.A summary of
maintenance activities can be found in Table 1.
Because the soil medium filters contaminants from runoff,the cation exchange capacity of the soil
media will eventually be exhausted.When the cation exchange capacity of the soil media decreases,
change the soil media to prevent contaminants from migrating to the groundwater, or from being
discharged via an underdrain outlet. Using small shrubs and plants instead of larger trees will make
it easier to replace the media with clean material when needed.
Page:!11 1113 f 'm.
Cold ClTir'Tiate C&nsideratioIns,
Never store snow in bioretention areas. The Operation and Maintenance plan must specify where
on-site snow will be stored. All snow dumps must comply with MassDEP'sguidance. When
bioretention areas are located along roads, care must be taken during plowing operations to
prevent snow from being plowed into the bioretention areas. If snow is plowed into the cells, runoff
may bypass the cell and drain into downgradient wetlands without first receiving the required water
quality treatment, and without recharging the groundwater.
0�peira't�ioin
Itl ii s t o I I a t III o i�i s
• Excavation: Excavate and compact the soil sub-grade.
• Base Preparation: Place and compact a gravel base, extending beyond the Turfstones by at
least 6 inches for residential use and 8 inches for vehicle loads.
• Bedding Sand: Spread and screed bedding sand to proper elevations. Ensure uniform
moisture content before placing the pavers.
• Placement: Lay the Turfstones with a minimum joint spacing of 1/16 inch.
Vibration: Use a high-frequency, low-amplitude plate vibrator with a rubber mat to vibrate
the Turfstones into the sand.
Y1 a'i��in t r"i a in c e
I[��Z e g u I a Iir- C I e a Iin III III,i g:
• Debris Removal: Sweep or blow off debris like leaves and dirt to prevent clogging2.
• Gentle Washing: Use a garden hose with a gentle spray nozzle for cleaning.Avoid pressure
washing to prevent damage.
Weed C;, IiPm t III ol:
• Inspection: Regularly check for weeds and remove them manually or use natural herbicides.
III p e ;.1 III" IIr--i A e III,S. "III III"ns:
• Drainage Check: Ensure the pavers are draining properly after heavy rains. Address any
pooling water by cleaning or replenishing fill material.
v
III°°°°III Material Mai III"i to IIIo°i a IIP'i c e:
• Replenishment: Over time,the fill material (soil or gravel) may displace. Replenish as needed
to maintain permeability.
r-i o III'-°i( Ice I a r--i a .,,,,,,,Ilr--n e IIr i t:
• De-Icing: Use non-abrasive de-icing agents and avoid metal shovels to prevent surface
damage.
n v I aIIr t i e s m c oIIr
v
hrif"'ILial
• Thorough Check: Conduct a detailed inspection at least once a year to identify and repair
any damage.
i��
0 el r'at qi�o r'i
• Site Preparation: Clear the area of vegetation and debris. Excavate to the required depth and
shape.
• Filter Layer: Place a filter fabric or a layer of gravel to prevent soil from moving through the
rip-rap.
• Placement: Use a well-graded mixture of rock sizes. Place the largest stones at the bottom
and work upwards, ensuring a stable and interlocked structure.
1\4 a I r")"t e r"i a in c e
II e LA a III I IIr--i p e ct,III o IIr-i s:
• Annual Checks: Inspect the rip-rap at least once a year and after major storms to identify any
displaced stones, slumping, or erosion at the edges.
• Post-Storm Inspections: Check for damage after heavy rains or storms. Promptly repair any
damage to prevent further erosion.
Weed aIi-id oIiI i t III„ .
• Vegetation Management: Remove any weeds or brush that may grow between the rocks to
maintain the integrity of the rip-rap.
• Cleaning: Remove accumulated sediment and debris to ensure the rip-rap remains effective
in controlling erosion.
III„ III III III" (-., II,,, , c �Iry i e Ili t:
• Damage Repair: If stones are displaced or the filter fabric is exposed, repair these areas
immediately to prevent progressive failure.
• Replenishment:Add new stones as needed to maintain the structure's effectiveness.
n v I a rtIII..i e s m c o IIr
P✓1ainte a e u ti g e t (Planr�in` 0nly)
�M�� ui ulu li
Activity Frequency
Replace Plantings $100/ea
Mulch $30/<y
Grass 10/ry
Replace entire media and all
vegetation $100/cy
Permeable Pavers $20/sf
Rip-Rap 8100/cy
12" Drainage Pipe $200/If
Drainage Structures $5,000/ea
*regular maintenance will be performed with Town forces.
rFBENCHMARKI
REUSE CLEAN BOULDERS 5'X5'RIP RAP
FROM RETAINING WALL. SPLASH PAD DOUBLE SWING GATE
SS SIG
RESET GUARDRAIL-- REMOVE AND
RESET GUARDRAIL
REMOVE AND
NATIVE TREE VER
RESET GUY WIRE 25—
BIORETENTION AREA NO.1 RESET MW CO 25-25—
... . . . . . . . .
41- BIORETENTION AREA NO.2
—25 -%T1
AN
2
OHW
FF F
Z F1 F-
1Z Z FZ FZ
4- -4j FZ
'T
Fz -LINED SWA RIPRAP LE
FZ r
NATIVE -77
0 ONE vvmf ol%,31� 16 u,
_N
PLANTINGS
'--MIN.5'(TYP. BOAT RACKS
oU,u
SIGN TRAIL
+4-PARKING ON
(6)8'X20-BOAT RACK
T_ I
RESET MW COVER
_1 _
(2)12'X20'BOAT RACK
4- RESET MW CQ
WIR >
'j
8'WIDE BOAT LAUNCH WITH 4�` + 25
z U114L vWky
"NO TRAILER ACCESS"SIGN
REVETMENT(SEE DETAIL I_1 7.
JF 25�No DISTURB ZONE
SIGN T
SHEET CD-5) (2)LOCKING
++
BOLL,n�RDS'
MIN 8'(Ty P.) RECYCLING -1 R36 0'
RECEPTACLES 7R54 0'
A,\
ONE WAY SIGN OH, 04 0
OHW CHW VV--
72-
-T- ————————
8'WIDE STONE FILLED PERMEABLE 41
—25_7_7
WITH 12% 25
PAVER BOAT LAUNCH
SLOPE(SEE DETAIL SHEET CD-5)
NATIVE TREES 7�77 SIGN"HANDICAP
WOOD POST WITH(TYP.) EXISTING )��P PARKING"
RESET E
ROP
KIOSKED FENCING
E
A-N
4
MSE BLOCK WALL VV
(SEE DETAIL
SHEET CD-5) K
—————— BENCHMARKI
———————— ——- REMOVE AND REPLACE SPIKE 01
FENCING(TYP.) EXISTING STONE ROCK BANK ELEV=117.78'1 '6
BENCHMARK ALONG FACE OF WALL
SPIKE
ELEV=109.32'
LEGEND
GRAVEL FILLED PAVERS <
GRASS FILLED PAVERS
BIORETENTION AREA
REVETMENT
RIP RAP
A FLARED END STRUCTURE
PLANOVERFLOW STRUCTURE
SCALE:1 20'
Scale 11. 20'
Date JULY 2024 NORTH LAKE COCHICHEWICK BOAT LAUNCH
119 x
ENVIRONMENTAL
TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER,MA Sheet No.
Job No. 22003302 o
01111",\ M <
IN I
Designed by THIS LINE IS ONE INCH
JLV
gw LONG WHEN PLOTTED AT
Drawn by FULL SCALE
PINK LE ON A 22"X
1
PARTNERS AES FIG. 1
Checked by RJP 34"DRAWING BMP LOCATION MAP
Al'Ap x Corniu�u',,y
MAR�DATE DESCRIPTION Approved by RJP