Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2001-05-14TOM REILLY ATTORNEY GENERAL THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSET~fe~i¥~-~ OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GEN n:r°w~oRTbl CLERk. WESTERN MASSACHUSETTS DIVISION 436 DW{GI~ STREET SPmNOrm~D, mAss^c~usr, l'rs O~ ~_03 (413) 784-1240 September 18, 2001 Joyce A. Bradshaw, Town Clerk 120 Main Street North Andover, MA 01845 North Andover Annual Town Meeting of May 14, 2001 -- Case # 1687 Warrant Articles # 18, 19, 20, 21, & 22 (General) Warrant Articles # 27, 29, & 30 (Zoning) Dear Ms. Bradshaw: I return the amendments to the town by-laws adopted under Articles 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 27, and 29 of the ~warrant for the North Andover town meeting that convened on May 14, 2001, with the approval of this Office. Article 27 - Article 27 amends the town's zoning by-laws by amending Section 8.8 "Adult Use Zone," Subsection 2. The existing text of Subsection 2 provides as follows: Adult uses may not be located A. within five hundred feet (500') of any Residential Zoning Districts or within five hundred (500') feet of any church, school, park, playfield, or other location where large numbers of minors regularly congregate .... According to the materials submitted to us for review Subsection 2 (A), as amended, would now provides as follows: Adult uses may not be located: A. within five hundred feet (500') of the property line of any Residential Zoning District, church, school, park, playfield, or other location where large numbers of minors wou. M congregate .... (Emphasis added.) We disapprove and delete the above underlined text. [Disapproval # 1 of 2] because it is vague and confusing as to render it inconsistent with state law and the Constitution. O'Connell v. Brockton Board of Appeals, 344 Mass. 208, 210-21 (1962) ("A by-law imposing [zoning] restrictions on the use of property ought not to stand when it is so vague and ambiguous that its meaning can only be guessed at.") The above underlined text is void vagueness because one is left to discern at one's peril the migratory habits of younger populations, which might even be seen as unlawful delegation of zoning functions to such variable devices. The special permit granting authority and those whose property and business interests would be governed by this by-law would have much difficulty in ascertaining whether a particular location within the town falls within the prohibition. By mandating that no adult entertainment be located less than 1,000 feet from a location that could change from day to day, hour to hour, is an insufficient guide to those whose property and business interests would be affected thereby. If there are places that the Town Meeting feels now have sufficiently established themselves as places of congregation for young people, then it could - on such finding - specify distance separations therefrom. But distances defined in tenx~s of where young people may from time to time congregate would appear to violate Section 5 of the Zoning Act, which requires all zoning designations be undertaken solely in confo~-~nity to the Act and not otherwise. Of course, in the context ora special permit application, the special permit granting authority could, inter alia, impose conditions of this sort but upon findings then applicable. Moreover, no standards or criteria are provided by which anyone is able to determine the requisite size of the "group" of minors whose congregating triggers a violation of this section. The special permit granting authority and those whose property and business interests would be governed by this by-law would have much difficulty in ascertaining whether a particular location within the town falls within the prohibition. For this reason we disapprove and delete the above underlined text. Article 30 - I return the amendments to the town by-laws adopted under Article 30 of the warrant for the North Andover town meeting that convened on May 14, 2001, with the approval of this Office, except as provided below. Article 30 amends the town's zoning by-laws by adding a new Section 8.10 "Lot/Slope Requirements." Subsection 1 (b) of the proposed by-law amendment provides: The provisions of this Subsection 8.10 shall not apply to building lots in a definitve subdivision plan submitted in accordance with M.G.L. Chapter 41 in order to obtain the protections afforded by M.G.L. Chapter 40A, Section 6. In addition, the provisions of this Subsection 8.10 shall not apply to building lots in a definitive subdivision ~lan approved prior to the enactment of this Subsection 8.10. The provisions of this Subsection 8.10 shall not apply to building lots on a plan subject to M.G.L. Chapter 41, Section 81P approved prior to the first date of publication of notice of this bylaw. (Emphasis added.) The above language is disapproved and deleted [Disapproval # 2 of 21. The basis for the disapproval is that Subsection 1 (b) is inconsistent with the uniformity provision contained in G.L.c. 40A, § 4. Section 4 provides, in pertinent part, that "any zoning.., by-law which divides.., towns into districts shall be uniform within the district for each class or kind of structures or uses permitted." The uniformity requirement of Section 4 is based on the principles of equal treatment. A zoning by-law is to be applied uniformly to all property located within a particular district, and all owners of properties in that district must be subjected to the same restrictions for the common benefit of all. SCIT, Inc. v. Planning Board of Braintree, 19 Mass. App. Ct. 101,108 (1984), citing Everpure Ice Mfg. Co. v. Board of Lawrence, 324 Mass. 433, 439 (1949). We are mindful, however, that there are exceptions to the uniformity provision of Chapter 40A, Section 4. The SCIT case states that the Zoning Act sanctions certain exceptions to the uniformity provision of Section 4. These exceptions are: Chapter 40A, § 6, relating to existing structures and uses; and Chapter 40A, 8§ 9 and 10, relating to special permits and variances. SCIT, 19 Mass. App. Ct. at 108. "These exceptions aside, § 4 does not contemplate, once a district is established and uses within it authorized as of right, conferral on local zoning boards ora roving and virtually unlimited power to discriminate as to uses between landowners similarly situated." Id. at 108. Therefore, in the absence of at least one of the foregoing statutory exceptions, it is not permissible to single out one lot and impose restrictions upon that lot that are less onerous than those imposed upon other lots similarly situated. Whitemore v. Building Inspector of Falmouth, 313 Mass. 248, 249 (1943). The first sentence of Section 1 (b) recognizes the protections accorded to definitive subdivisions plans under G.L.c. 40A, § 6. Section 6 is a "grandfathering" provision that allows land shown on subdivision plans that have been submitted to the planning board for approval to be governed by the zoning by-laws in effect on the date of submission, provided written notice of such submission has been given to the town clerk before the effective date of the by-law. If such definitive plan or an amendment thereof is finally approved, the plan will be governed by the by-law in effect on the date of submission for eight years from the date of the endorsement of such approval. The second sentence of Subsection 1 (b) would expand the eight year protection given under G.L.c. 40A, § 6, and indefinitely exempt lots shown on a definitive subdivision plan approved prior to the enactment of proposed by-law from the lot and slope requirements of the proposed by-law. When the eight year protections given under G.L.c. 40A, § 6, expires those subdivision plans approved prior to the enactment would still be exempt from the provisions of the proposed by-law. Lots shown on a definitive subdivision plan approved after the enactment of the proposed by-law would only enjoy those protections given under G.L.c. 40A, § 6, and once those protections expire, the plans would be subject to the lot and slope requirements of the proposed by-law. Thus, the second sentence of Subsection 1 (b) will result in non-unifom~ treatment of lots shown on subdivision plans identical in all respects but for the date in which the subdivision plans showing such lots were approved. The uniformity provision was enacted to avoid this type of unequal treatment. The third sentence of Subsection 1 (b) suffers from a similar uniformity problem. The third sentence of Subsection 1 (b) would indefinitely protect G.L.c. 41, § 81P plans - - also referred to as "Approval Not Required" or "ANR" Plans - - approved prior to the first date of the publication of notice of the by-law from the lot and slope requirements of the proposed by-law. Lots shown on ANR plans approved after the first date of the publication of notice of the by-law would not enjoy such indefinite protection and are only protected to the extent accorded under G.L.c. 40A, § 6. Again, the uniformity provision of G.L.c. 40A, § 4, was enacted to avoid this type of unequal treatment. For these reasons we disapprove and delete the above underlined text. NOTE: We ask that you forward to us a copy of the final text of the amendments adopted under Articles 27 and 30 after making the deletions identified in this letter. It will be sufficient to send us a copy of the by-laws as published pursuant to G.L.c. 40, § 32. Very lxuly Yours, THOMAS F. REILLY ATTORNEY GE~L ~y./Kelli E. Lav~renc)~, Assistant Attorney General Municipal Law ~ 436 Dwight Street Springfield, MA 01103-1317 (413) 784-1240, x 46 enc. pc: Town Counsel F:\USER$'dtJTCHIE\WP61 \DOC$\TOWNS\NOAlqDOVR~ 1687.wpd 4 TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK .'120 MAIN STREET NORTH ANDOVER, MASSACHUSETTS 01845 Joyce A. Bradshaw, CMMC Telephone (978) 688-9501 Town Clerk Fax (978) 688-9556 E-mail jbmdshaw~,towno fnorthandover.eom This is to certify that the following vote was taken on Article 18 at the Adjourned Annual Town Meeting for the Town of North Andover held May, 15, 2001: Article 18. Amend Town Code - Add Chapter 177 - Water Use Restriction Bylaw. UNANIMOUSLY VOTED to amend the Code of the Town of North Andover by adding a new Chapter 177 to be known as "WATER" and add Article I - "Water Use Restriction" which will become the Town of North Andover Water Use Restriction Bylaw to read as follows: CHAFFER 177 WATER USE RESTRICTION BYLAW 17%1. Authority This Bylaw is adopted by the Town under its police powers to protect public health and welfare and its powers under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40, Section 21 et seg. and implements the Town's authority to regulate water use pursuant to Massachusetts General Law Chapter 41, Section 69B. This bylaw also implements the Town's authority under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40, Section 4lA, conditioned upon a declaration of water supply emergency issued by the Department of Environmental Protection. 17%2. Purpose The purpose of this bylaw is to protect, preserve and maintain public health, safety and welfare whenever there is in force a State of Water Supply Conservation or State of Water Supply Emergency by providing for enforcement of any duly imposed restrictions, requirements, provisions or conditions imposed by the Town or by the Department of Environmental Protection. ATTEST: A True Copy Town Clerk 17%3. Def'mitions Person - Shall mean any individual, corporation, trust, partnership or association, or other entity. Public Water Supply - Shall mean the North Andover Municipal Water Supply System withdrawing water from Lake Coehichewick. State of Water SuDolv Emergency - Shall mean a State of Water Supply Emergency declared by the Department of Environmental Protection under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 21G, Sections 15-17. State of Water Supply Conservation - Shall mean a State of Water Supply Conservation declared by the Town pursuant to Section 177-4 of this bylaw. Water Users or Water Consumers - Shall mean all public and private users of the Town's public water system, irrespective of any person's responsibility for billing purposes for Water used at any particular facility/location. Director - Shall mean the Director of the Division of Public Works for the Town of North Andover. 177-4. Declaration of State of Water Supply Conservation The Town, through the Board of Selectman, may declare a State of Water Supply Conservation within the Town's Public Water System upon a determination by the Director that a shortage of water exists and conservation measures are appropriate to ensure an adequate supply of water to all water consumers. Public notice of a State of Water Supply Conservation shall be given under Section 177.6 of this bylaw before it may be enforced. 17%5. Restricted Water Uses A declaration of a State of Water Supply Conservation shall include one or more of the following restrictions, conditions, or requirements limiting the use of water as necessary to protect the public water supply. The applicable restrictions, conditions or requirements shall be included in the Public Notice required under Section 177.6. Outdoor Water Use Hours - Outdoor water use by water users is permitted only during daily periods of low demand, at night or early morning. Odd/Even Day Outdoor Water Use - Outdoor water use by water users with odd numbered addresses is restricted to odd numbered days. Outdoor water use by water users with even numbered addresses is restricted to even number days. 3. Outdoor Water Use Ban - Outdoor water use by water users is prohibited. 17%6. Public Notification of State of Water Supply Conservation Notification of DEP Notification of any provision, restriction, requirement or condition imposed by the Town as part of a State of Water Supply Conservation shall be published in a newspaper of general circulation within the Town, or by such other means reasonably calculated to reach and inform all users of town water of the State of Water Supply Conservation. Any restriction imposed under Section 177.5 shall not be effective until such notification is provided. Notification of the State of Water Supply Conservation shall also be simultaneously provided to the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection. 17%7. Termination of State of Water Supply Conservation: Notice A State of Water Supply Conservation may be terminated by a majority vote of the Board of Selectmen upon a determination that the water supply shortage no longer exists. Public notification of the tei-minafiou of a State of Water Supply Conservation shall be given in the same manner required by Section 177.6. 17%8. State of Water Supply Emergency: Compliance with DEP Orders Upon notification to the public that the Department of EnvirOmental Protection has issued a State of Water Supply Emergency, no person shall violate any provision, restriction, requirement, condition of any order approved or issued by the Department intended to bring about an end to the State of Water Supply Emergency. 17%9. Violation and Penalties Any person violating this bylaw shall be subject to a warning for the first offense and thereafter shall be liable to the Town in the amount of $50.00 for the second violation, and $100 for each subsequent violation, which shall inure to the Town for such uses as the Board of Selectmen may direct. Fines shall be recovered by indictment, or on complaint before the District Court, or by non-criminal disposition in accordance with Section 21D of Chapter 40 of the provisions of the Massachusetts General Laws. For purposes of non-criminal disposition, the enforcing person(s) shall be any police officer of the Town of North Andover. Each day of violation shall constitute a separate offense. 177-10. Severabliity The invalidity of any portion or provision of this bylaw shall not invalidate any other portion or provision thereof. VOTED MAY 15, 2001 TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK 120 MAIN STREET NORTH ANDOVER, MASSACHUSETTS 01845 Joyce A. Bra&haw, CMMC Telephone (978) 688-9501 Town Clerk Fax (978) 688-9556 E~mmil jbradshaw@towno fnorthandover, com This is to certify that the following vote was taken on Article 19 .at the Adjourned Annual Town Meeting for the Town of North Andover held. May 15, 2001: Article 19. Automatic Lawn Irrigation Bylaw. UNANIMOUSLY VOTED that the Town amend the Code of North Andover by adding to Chapter 177 "WATER" - ARTICLE II - Sections 177.11 to 177.15 to be known as the Town of North AndoverAutomafic Lawn Irrigation System Bylaw to read as follows: CHAPTER 177 -WATER-ARTICLE II 'AUTOMATIC LAWN IRRIGATION SYSTEM BYLAW 177-11. Registration All automatic lawn irrigation systems connected to the municipal water system of the Town of North Andover shall be registered with the Division of Public Works (DPW). A fee may be charged for this registration. The Board of Selectmen shall set registration fees. 177-12. Backflow Prevention The Town of North Andover shall be protected from a backflow condition from all automatic lawn irrigation systems connected to the municipal water system by the installation of a backflow prevention device approved by the Division of Public Works. Each backflow prevention device shall be registered with the Division of Public Works. All new or existing residential, municipal, commercial and industrial prOperty owners are required to install.or have in place, a backflow prevention device on their automatic lawn irrigation system. The installation shall be in compliance with 310 CMR 22.22. These devices must be installed on the discharge side of the water meter, preferably indoors, but can be located outside provided they can easily be removed to protect them from damage by freezing. ATTEST: A True Copy '~ewn Reduced Pressure Zone and Pressure Vacuum Breaker type devices shall be tested upon initial installation and thereafter in accordance with 310 CMR 22.22 17%13. Rain Sensors Installation of new automatic lawn irrigation systems connected to the municipal water supply in'the Town of North Andover shall be equipped with a rain sensor approved by the Division of Public Works so that watering will be automatically prevented during or after a rain storm. Any upgrade or repair of an existing automatic lawn irrigation system shall include the installation of an approved rain sensor if the same is not already installed and in good working' condition. The Division of Public Works shall maintain a list, available to the Public, of approved rain sensors. 17%14. Violations and Penalties Any person violating this bylaw shall be subject to a warning for the' frrst offense and thereafter shall be liable to the Town in the amount of $50.00 for the second violation, and $100 for each subsequent violatiOn, which shall inure to the Town for such uses as the Board of Selectmen may direct. Fines shall be recovered by indictment, or on complaint before the District Court, or by non-criminal disposition in accordance with Section 21D of Chapter 40 of the provisiOns of the Massachusetts General Laws. For purposes of non-criminal disposition, the enfoming person(s) shall be any police officer of the Town. Each day of violation shall constitute a separate offense. 17%15. Severabilitv The invalidity of any portion or provision of the Bylaw shall not invalidate any other portion or provision thereof. VOTED MAY 15, 2001 TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK 120 MAIN STREET NORTH ANDOVER, MASSACHUSETTS 01845 Joyce A. Bradshaw, CMMC Telephone (978) 688-9501 Town Clerk Fax (978) 688-9556 E-mail |bradshaw(&townofnorthandover.com This is to certify that the following vote on Article 20 was taken at the Adjourned Annual Town Meeting for the Town of North Andover held May 15, 2001: VOTED BY CLEAR MAJORITY to adopt Article 20 as printed in the Warrant with the following amendment: Add new Section 4 - Amend the first sentence of Section 5A of Chapter 170 by deleting the phrase''in the town" and replacing with the words "along or across any public way within the parts of the Town listed in Section 3" Article 20. Amend Town Code - Chapter 170 - Underground Utilitie~ Bylaw Amendments. VOTED BY CLEAR MAJORITY to amend Chapte~ 170- Underground Utilities Bylaw as follows: 1. Add the following Definitions to Section 1 of Chapter 170 of Code of the Town of North Andover: Alternative Coordination Plan - A plan to coordinate the implementation of the utility specific plans required by this underground bylaw. In the event that the utilities and the Town are not able to reach agreement on any aspects of a negotiated project coordination plan, the Town will use reasonable discretion to establish an alternative coordination plan. The objective of this alternative coordination plan will be to use a single qualified general contractor to perform the excavation and civil work necessary for the installation of all of the underground facilities, including cable facilities, electric facilities, telephone facilities, and municipal facilities, contemplated by this underground bylaw, as well as a proposed formula for apportioning the cost of that qualified general contractor. This alternative project coordination plan will assume that each utility will directly install and energize its own cable and wire in the conduits and manholes constructed by the qualified general contractor. In establishing such alternative coordination plan, the Town shall be ATTEST: A ~t~ Copy Town (~erk guided by the objective of achieving efficient coordination among the utilities, a cost effective underground project, with the minimum disruption of the public way. Company Specifications - Detailed specifications provided by the each utility regarding the number and size of duct banks, the type and quantity of cable or wire, and the number and precise specifications of manholes and hand holes, the description of and quantification of the equipment necessary to construct and install customer's service facilities, and all other specifications regarding all other facilities necessary to replace overhead service in the area of the coxnm~mity covered by this bylaw, with underground service, all prepared in sufficient detail to be included in a request for bid for a qualified general contractor. Cost Per Linear Foot - When reporting the cost of demolition or const~'ucfion per linear foot, the cost should be reported per linear foot of the overhead or underground system. For example the 1,000 feet of overhead or underground facilities that are located on 1,000 feet of one side of a public way would be reported as 1,000 feet of overhead facilities or underground facilities xemoved or constructed. If a particular utility has two lines or two conduits on a given set of poles or in a given duct bank, and therefore 2,000 feet of overhead wire or underground wire in this 1,000 foot span of the public way, the cost per linear foot must be reported using the 1,000 feet of the public way as the denominator, and must not be reported using the 2,000 feet of wire as the denominator. Customer's Service Facilities - The facilities required to connect a customer's building or structure to the underground service mandated by this bylaw, which customer's service facilities are more specifically defined in Section 22I of Chapter 166 of the Massachusetts General Laws; Direct Cost of Demolition and Construction - The direct cost of construction labor, construction materials, and construction equipment used to implement the demolition and construction mandated by this bylaw. This shall include the direct cost of conshuction labor, construction materials, and construction equipment used to install the customer's service facilities defined by Section 22I of Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 166. Direct costs of demolition and construction shall also include the following costs: (A) the direct cost of completing an "Existing Conditions Plan", to the extent such cost is incurred at the request of the Town in order to exp .edite the schedule for the underground project, or incurred directly by the Town in order to expedite said schedule, and then reimbursed by the utility; (B) interest on any amounts spent for such direct costs in excess of the two (2%) annual expenditure required by Section 5A of this bylaw, to the extent such excess expenditure is directly associated with in an effort expedite the actual construction schedule at the request of the Town. (C) The direct cost of any communication ducts installed at the request of the Town, which communication ducts are to be reserved municipal use. Petition - The petition, timely filed, that is required by section 22D of Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 166, and Section 5B clause (1) of this bylaw, relating to the permission to install underground facilities mandated by this by-law. Such petition shall request permission for the shared use of common duct banks and common trenches by and among other utilities and the Town, or.include a justification explaining why such shared use of common duct banks and common trenches is not possible. Plan for Continuation of its Services, for their Replacement with Underground Facilities - The plan, timely filed, that is required by section 22D of G.L. Chapter 166, and Section 5B clause (2) of this bylaw, relating to the removal of that particular ufility's overhead wires and associated overhead equipment and the construction of a particular utility's underground equipment to provide service to consumers in the geographic area covered by this by-law. This utility specific plan that meets the requirements of this bylaw must include at a minimum the following required components: 1) The company's specifications for the underground project; 2) An estimate of the total direct cost of demolition and. construction of the project which includes the cost of installing customer's service facilities; 3) An'estimate of the total salvage value of the overhead property to be removed; 4) A statement of the total company revenues received in the community in the preceding calendar year, and an estimate of the total company revenues to be received in the community in the current year; 5) An estimate of the total duration of the demolition and construction project assuming that the company allocates and expends 2% of such annual revenues (plus the reasonable salvage value of the removed overhead equipment) to the direct cost of demolition and construction of that company's project; 6) A proposed coordination plan that describes a plan for utilizing a single qualified general contractor to perform the excavation and civil work necessary for the installation of all of the underground facilities, including cable facilities, electric facilities, telephone 'facilities, and municipal facilities, contemplated by this underground by-law, as well as a proposed formula for apportioning the cost of that qualified general contractor among the various users of the underground facilities constructed; 7) A statement that the utility will participate in good faith in a negotiation conducted by the Town, that includes all of the utilities covered by this bylaw, in which the Town attempts to develop a negotiated coordination plan that is acceptable to each utility and to the Town; 8) A statement that the company's plan will be implemented in a fashion that complies with any alternative coordination plan that may be established by the Town; Such plan must be filed no later December 31 of the calendar year prior to the calendar year in which thc first expenditures for thc direct cost of demolition and construction are required to made. Negotiated Project Coordination Plan - The-Town will review the coordination plans that are included in the cable company plan, electric company plan, and telephone company plan filed with the Board of Selectmen pursuant to this by law. The Town will host a project coordination meeting to be attended by representatives of the Town and each of said utilities, and use reasonable efforts to negotiate project coordination plan that is acceptable to each of said utilities and the Town. The objective of this negotiated coordination plan will be to use a single qualified general contractor to perform the excavation and civil work necessary for the installation of all of the underground facilities, including cable facilities, electric facilities, telephone facilities, and municipal facilities, contemplated by this underground by-law, as well as a proposed formula for apportioning the cost of that qualified general contractor. This negotiated project coordination plan will assume that each utility will directly install and energize its own cable and wire in the conduits and manholes constructed by the qualified general contractor. In negotiating such coordination plan, the Town shall be guided by the objective of achieving efficient coordination among the utilities, a cost effective project, with the minimum, disruption of the public way. Qualified General Contractor - A contractor with extensive experience in desi~cming and constructing underground utilities in Massachusetts, as evidenced by letters of recommendation from Massachusetts utilities that have contracted for the services of such qualified general contractor in the past. Statement - .Annual statement, timely filed, that is required by section 22D of Chapter 166 of the Massachusetts General Laws, and Section 5B clause 4 of this bylaw. This annual statement must, at a minimum, include the following information regarding the removal of overhead facilities and construction of replacement underground facilities, completed by said utility in the prior calendar year: a) Linear feet of overhead facilities removed; b) Street names on which such removal OCCurred; c) Direct cost of demolition associated with such removal for the calendar year in question; d) Direct cost of demolition associated with such removal per linear foot of overhead facilities removed; a) Linear feet of underground facilities constructed; b) Street names on which underground construction occurred; c) Direct cost of construction for the calendar year in question; d) Direct cost of construction per linear foot of such construction completed; a) Number of customer service facilities completed; b) Street names on which customer service facilities occurred; c) Direct cost of construction associated with customer service facilities constructed for the calendar year in question; d) Direct cost of construction per customer service facility constructed. 4. a) The dollar amount of the direct cost of demolition and construction spent in any year prior to the preceding calendar year, which amount was in excess of the 2% of thc standard defined in section 22D of Chapter 166 of the General Laws, and which excess amount the utility is allocating as a credit to reduce the dollar expenditures required by this by-law for the direct cost of demolition and construction in the calendar year that is the focus of this financial report; 5. a) Gross Revenues derived from that utility's custom~rs in North Andover in the calendar year preceding the expenditures reported in items 1, 2, and 3 above; b) Representation that the amounts spent by such utility for the direct cost of demolition and construction, as itemized above, in items 1, 2, and 3 plus any credit as described in item 4, equals or exceeds 2% of the gross revenue reported in Sa) above. Add the following paragraph to the end of Section 5A of Cha~ter 170 of the Code of the Town of North Andover: In preparation for making the minimum expenditures required by Section 5A, each utility covered by this bylaw, shall, file with the Board of Selectmen the petition as required by Section 22 of Chapter 166 of the Massachusetts General Laws, and by Section 5B, clause (1) of this bylaw, and also file the plan as required by Section 22D of Chapter 166 of the Massachusetts General Laws, and by Section 5B clause (2) of this bylaw. In order to enable the Town to monitor compliance with this bylaw, each utility covered by this bylaw shall file the statement with the Board of Selectmen, that is required by Section 22D of Chapter 166 of the Massachusetts General Laws, and Section 5B, clause (4) of this bylaw. Any petition, plan, or statement filed by a utility pursuant to this bylaw must meet the minimum content requirements and timely filing requirements defined in this bylaw. Add the following Two Sections to Chapter 170 of the Code of the Town of North Andover: Section 6. Installation of Customer's Service Facilities Any utility providing underground replacement facilities pursuant to this bylaw, shall also install customer's service facilities as defined by Section 221 of chapter 166 of the General Laws. Such installation of customer's service facilities shall be incorporated into the plan filed with board of selectmen pursuant to Section 5B clause (2) of this bylaw, and the cost associated with such installation of customer's service facilities shall be included in the report of direct cost of demolition and construction reported to the board of selectmen pursuant to Section 5B clause (4) of this bylaw. It is the intent of this Section that the cost of the installation of customer service facilities shall be reimbursed to the utility through the 2% surcharge contemplated by section 22D of Chapter 166 of the General Laws. Section 7. Severability If any provision of this bylaw is determined to be invalid, such determination shall not affect the validity of the other provisions of this bylaw, which other provisions shall remain in full force and effect. ,,lmend the first sentence of Section 5,4 of Chapter 170 by deleting the phrase "in the town" and replacing with the words "along or across any public way within the parts of the Town listed in Section $" VOTED MAY 15, 2001 TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK 120 MAIN STREET NORTH ANDOVER, MASSACHUSETTS 01845 Joyce A. Bra&haw, CMMC Telephone (978) 688-9501 Town Clerk Fax (978) 6889556 E-mail |bradshaw(~townofnorthandover.com This is to certify that the following vote on Article 21 Was taken at the Adjourned Annual Town Meeting for the Town of North Andover held May 15, 2001: Article 21. Amend Town Code - Chapter 170 - Underground Utilities Bylaw. VOTED BY CLEAR MAJORITY to amend the Town Code, Chapter 170 - Underground Utilities Bylaw by inserting a new subsection to Section 3 to read: D) Old Common: along Osgood Street from Bay State Road to the intersection of Andover Street. Along Andover Street from Academy Road to the intersection with Chestnut Street, along Massachusetts Avenue from 200 feet northwest of the intersection with Osgood Street through the Old Center to Salem Street and Johnson Street to Milk Street and along Great Pond Road from Academy Road 200 feet to the east toward Stevens Street. Michael Lenihan and Others VOTED MAY 15, 2001 - VOTED AFTER ARTICLE 20 ATTEST: A True Copy Town Cl~rk TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK 120 MAIN STREET NORTH ANDOVER, MASSACHUSETTS 01845 Joyee A. Bradshaw, CMMC Telephone (978) 688-9501 Town Clerk Fax (978) 688-9556 E-mail ]bradshaw~_,townofnorthandover. com This is to certify that the following vote was taken on Article 22 at the Adjourned Annual Town Meeting for the Town of North Andover held May 15, 2001: Article 22. Amend Town Code - Chapter 115 - Trash Collection - Andrew Circle. To see if the Town will vote to amend Chapter 115 of the Code of thc Town of North Andover, Section 1, Paragraph A, section (3) by adding the following at the end of this section: "Not withstanding the forgoing, the Town will provide customary residential trash pick up for the owner oecupiad Town House Homes of Andrew Circle. Townhouse Homes is a non-profit organization of 8 residential units per building (3 buildings total)."; and further to appropriate $4,000 to accomplish this process. Or take any other action relative thereto. Denise Desmond and Others VOTED BY MAJORITY VOTE to adopt as printed in the warrant with the following amendment: UPON MOTION MADE BY MICHAEL GARON AND DULY SECONDED TO: DELETE "and further to appropriate $4,000 to accomplish this process." CLEAR MAJORITY VOTE - MAY 15, 2001 ARTICLE 22 VOTED MAY 15, 2001 ATTEST: A True Copy 'l~wn TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK 120 MAIN STREET NORTH ANT)OVER, MASSACHUSETTS 01845 Joyce A. Bradshaw, CMMC Town Clerk E-mail jbradshaw~towno£nordaandover.com Telephone (978) 688-9501 Fax (978)688-9556 This is to certify that the following vote on Article 27 was taken at the Adjourned Annual Town Meeting for the Town of North Andover held May 15, 2001 and as amended by Attorney General Case #1687 Dated September 18, 2001: Article 27. Amend Zoning Bylaw - Section 8.8 - Adult Use Zone. To see if the Town will vote to amend Section 8.8 Adult Use Zone subsection 2 - Separation Distances as follows: Amend item a) from the current language: "within five hundred (500') feet of any Residential Zoning Districts or within five hundred (500') feet of any church, school, park, playfield, or other location where large numbers of minors regularly congregate." Shall be amended to now read: "within five hundred (500') feet of the property line of any church, school, park, playfield, or other location where large numbers of minors would congregate." Amend item b) from the current language "within five hundred feet (500') of any other adult use as defined herein." Shall be amended to now read: "within one-thousand feet (1000') of the property line on which any other adult use as defined herein either resides or has been approved for adult uses." John R. Leemah, Jr. and Others UNANIMOUSLY VOTED to adopt Article 27 as printed in the Warrant (as shown above) with the following amendments: Amendment 1: UNANIMOUSLY VOTED to insert "Residential Zoning Districts" in Paragraph 1 (one) line 5 (five) "after any and before church". Amendment 2: VOTED to delete the second paragraph beginning "Amend item b)" in its entirety. VOTED YES 70 NO 58 VOTED MAY 15, 2001 AS VOTED BY ARTICLE 27 ADJOURNED 2001 ANNUAL TOWN MEETING TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER ZONING BYLAW SECTION 8.8 SUBSECTION 2 - SEPARATION DISTANCES - TO READ AS FOLLOWS REFLECTING ATTORNEY GENERAL DISAPPROVAL #1 OF 2 CASE #1687 DATED SEPTEMBER 18, 2001. 2. Separation Distances: Adult uses may not be located: a. within five hundred feet (500') of the property line of any Residential Zoning District, church, school, park, playfield. b. within five hundred feet (500') of any other adult use as defined herein; c. within three hundred feet (300') of any establishment licensed under MGL Ch. 138, Sec. 12. TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER · OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK 120 MAIN STRF, ET NORTH ANDOVER, MASSACHUSETTS 01845 Joyc¢ A. Bradshaw, CMMC Town Clerk E-mail jbmdshaw~towno fnorthandover.eom Telephone (978) 688-9501 Fax (978)688-9556 This is to certify that the following vote was taken on Article 29 of the Adjourned Annual Town Meeting for the Town of North Andover held May 15, 2001: Article29. Amend Zoning Bylaw- Section 8.7 Growth Management. UNANIMOUSLY VOTED to amend Section 8.7 of the Town of North Andover Zoning Bylaw, Growth Management Bylaw to extend the expiration date from July 1, 2001 to July 1, 2002 to read as follows: c) The provisions of this Section 8.7 shall expire on July 1, 2002; however by a vote of Town Meeting before said date, the provisions -of this Section 8.7 may be extended for an additional four years in order to continue municipal comprehensive planning studies necessary to promote orderly growth. In the event such action is taken by Town Meeting prior to July 1, 2002 these provisions shall not be construed to have lapsed on such date. Alison Lescarbeau and Others VOTED MAY 15, 2001 TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER ZONING BYLAW - SECTION 8.7 GROWTH MANAGEMENT - AS AMENDED BY ARTICLE 29 TO READ AS FOLLOWS: 8.7 GROWTH MANAGEMENT INTENT AND PURPOSE This Section 8.7 is adopted pursuant to the provisions of M.G.L., c. 40A and the Home Rule Amendment, Article 89 of the Massachusetts Constitution, for the following purposes: A True CopF Town Clerk to ensure that growth occurs in an orderly and planned manner, at a rate that can be supported by Town services, while avoiding large year to year variations in the development rate; to allow the Town time to update its Master Plan and to provide the Town with time to study the effect of growth on the municipality's inbastmcture, character and municipal services; to allow the Town time to study, plan for, and provide an additional source of water; to relate the timing of residential development to the Town's ability to provide adequate public safety, schools, roads, municipal infrastructure, and human services at the level of quality which citizens expect, and within the Town's ability to pay under the financial limitations of Proposition 2 1/2. to preserve and enhance the exiting community character and value of property; and to allow departures from the strict application of the growth rate measures herein in order to encourage certain types of residential growth which address the homing needs of specific population groups or which provide significant reductions in the ultimate residential density of the Town. APPLICABILITY, EFFECT AND DEFINITIONS No building permit shall be issued for a new dwelling unit between May 6,1996 and July 1,1996 unless exempted by Section 8.7(6) herein. Beginning on July 1,1996, no building permit for a new dwelling unit or units shall be issued unless in accordance with the regulations of this Section 8.7 or unless exempted by Section 8.7(6) herein. The provisions of this Section 8.7 shall expire on July 1, 2002; however, by a vote of Town Meeting before said date, the provisions of this Section 8.7 may be extended for an additional five years in order to continue municipal comprehensive planning studies necessary to promote orderly growth. In the event such action is taken by Town Meeting prior to July 1, 2001 these provisions shall not be construed to have lapsed on such date. For the purposes of this Section 8.7, the following terms shall have the following meaning: "Growth Rate Limit" shall mean the maximum number of building permits that may be authorized in one Year, which shall be 80 permits. The Growth Rate Limit is based upon analysis of recent average growth rates and an analysis of the Town's current and future ability to provide essential local services such as public safety, schools, public works and human services. Units exempt under section 8.7(6) are included within the calculation of the Growth Rate Limit. "Development" shall mean a single parcel or set of contiguous parcels of land held in common ownership, regardless of foim, at any time on or after the date of adoption of this bylaw, for which one or more building permits will be sought. "Development Schedule" shall mean a schedule authorized by the Planning Board in accordance with Section 8.7(4), which outlines the maximum building permit issuance per development. "Developer" any individual who either as an individual, a beneficial owner of a real estate trust, a partner in a partnership, or an officer or owner of a corporation, requests one or more building permits for the construction of new dwelling units. "Year" shall mean the period beginning July 1 and ending June 30. PLANNED GROWTH RATE The Growth Rate Limit shall be based on a target growth rate of 80 dwelling units per year. In no case, however, shall the number of nonexempt building permits issued be reduced below 60 permits in any one year period. Whenever the number of building permits issued for new dwelling units exceeds the applicable Growth Rate Limit, the Building Inspector shall not issue building permits for any additional dwelling unit or units unless such unit or units are exempt from the provisions of this Section 8.7 under subsection 8.7(6) below. Building pemdts authorized under a Development Schedule, but not' issued during the scheduled period set forth in Section 8.7(4) shall not be counted in computing the applicable Growth Rate Limit. Building permits issued, but subsequently abandoned trader the provisions of the State Building Code, shall not be counted in computing the applicable Growth Rate Limit. DEVELOPMENT SCHEDULING This Section 8.7(4) shall apply to the following types of development which would result in the creation of new dwelling units; (a) definitive subdivision plans, (b) plans subject to M.G.L.c.41, s.81P (ANR); (c) special permits. In addition to the types of development described in paragraph 8.7(4)(a), the Planning Board is authorized, upon request from the Developer, to approve a development schedule for any other building lot or dwelling unit, specifying the month and year in which such lot/unit shall be eligible for a building permit. Dwelling units shall be considered as part of a single development, for purposes of development scheduling, if located on either a single parcel or on a set of contiguous parcels of land held by a Developer in common ownership, regardless of form, at any time on or after the date of adoption of this bylaw. Where consistent with the applicable Growth Rate Limit, building permits for the construction of new residential units in types of development set forth in Section 8.7(4)(a), shall be authorized only in accordance with the following table: Number of New dwelling units in development new dwelling units per Year Maximum Number of building permits for 1-5 (Total in Development) 6-10 5 11-20 6 21-30 7 3140 8 41-54 9 55-80 10 More than 80 12.5% of Total in Development Notwithstanding that a Development Schedule has been approved and recorded, the Planning Board shall not be required to authorize the issuance of the stated maximum number of building pemdts if the issuance of such permits would result in exceeding the Growth Rate Limit. Adoption of a Development Schedule shall not be construed as a commitment to issue building permits. The Planning Board shall not establish any Development Schedule which phases development for longer than a 10 year period. PROCEDURES FOR DEVELOPMENT SCHEDULES No building permits for new dwelling units shall be issued until the Development Schedule has been recorded and a certified copy of the Development Schedule has been filed with the Planning Board. Upon transfer of any lot or unit in the types of development subject to development scheduling, the deed shall reference the Development Schedule and state the earliest date on which construction may be commenced in accordance with the provisions of this bylaw. In order to be equitable to all Developers no more than 20% of the total available building permits under section 8.7(3)(a), in any Year, will be issued to any one Developer. Procedures for development schedules shall be in accordance with rules and regulations, consistent with the provisions of this bylaw, to be adopted by the Planning Board on or before July l, 1996. EXEMPTIONS The following developments are specifically exempt from the Growth Rate Limit and Development ScheduLing provisions of this by-law. The issuance of building peru-fits for these Developments shall count toward the Growth Rate Limit of 80 permits in a Year. Except that permits issued under subsection (a) below shall not count towards the Growth Rate Limit of 80 permits in a Year. An application for a building permit for the enlargement, restoration, or reconstruction of a dwelling in existence as of the effective date of this by-law, provided that no additional residential unit is created. /~1 lots created prior to May 6, 1996 are exempt from the provisions of this Section 8.7 of the Zoning Bylaw. Dwelling units for low and/or moderate income families or individuals, where all of the following conditions are met: Occupancy of the units is restricted to households qualifying under Local Initiative Program as administered by the Executive Office of Communities and Development; The affordable units are subject to a properly executed and recorded deed restriction running with the land which shall limit the succeeding resale price to an increase of 10 percent, plus any increase in the consumer price index, plus the cost of any improvements certified by the Building Inspector. Dwelling units for senior residents, where occupancy of the units is restricted to senior persons through a properly executed and recorded deed restriction running with the land. For purposes of this Section "senior" shall mean persons over the age of 55. Development projects which voluntarily agree to a minimum 40% permanent reduction in density,(buildable lots), below the density,(buildable lots), permitted under zoning and feasible given the environmental conditions of the tract, with the surplus land equal to at least ten buildable acres and permanently designated as open space and/or famdand. The land to be preserved shall be protected from development by an Agricultural Preservation Restriction, Conservation Restriction, dedication to the Town, or other similar mechanism approved by the Planning Board that will ensure its protection. Any tract of land existing and not held by a Developer in common ownership with an adjacent parcel on the effective date of this Section 8.7 shall receive a on~-fime exemption fi'om the Planned Growth Rate and Development Scheduling provisions for the purpose of constructing one single family dwelling unit on the parcel. If at the time a Development is ready for building perrnits,(ie, all other petraits from all other boards and commissions have been received and the project is in compliance with those permits),, and the Development Schedule does not accommodate issuing a building pemdt in that Year, one building permit will be issued per Year per Development until such time as de Development Schedule accommodates issuing building permits. ZONING CHANGE PROTECTION Any protection against zoning changes provided by M.G.L.c. 40A, s.6, shall be extended to the earliest date on which the final unit in the development could be authorized under this bylaw. SEVERABILITY The provisions of this by-law are hereby declared severable and if any provision shall be held invalid or unconstitutional, it shall not be construed to affect the validity or constitutionality of any of the remaining provisions of this by-law. TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK 120 MAIN STREET NORTH ANDOVER, MASSACHUSETTS 01845 Joyce A. Bradshaw, CMMC Town Clerk E-mail l'bradshaw~townofncrrthandover, com Telephone (978) 688-9501 Fax (978)688-9556 This is to certify that the following vote was taken on Article 30 at the Adjourned Annual Town Meeting for the Town of North Andover held May 15, 2001 and as Amended by Attorney General Case #1687 Dated September 18, 2001: Article 30. Adopt Section 8.10 - Lot/Slope Requirements. To see if the Town will vote to amend the North Andover Zoning Bylaw by adopting Section 8.10 - Lot/Slope Requirements, to read as follows: 8.10- Lot/Slope Requirements "1. Lot/Slope Requirements: In the residential provisions of this Section 8.10 shall apply: a. zoning districts the following Purpose: The purpose of this bylaw is to preserve and enhance the landscape by encouraging the maximum retention of natural topographic features, such as drainage swales, streams, slopes, ridge lines, rock outcroppings, vistas, natural plant fomtations and trees; to minimize water nmoff and soil-erosion problems incurred in grading of steep slopes; to encourage innovative architectural, landscaping, circulation and site design. For the purposes of this subsection, the tent, '~tatural" shall be defined as the condition of the ground surface as it exists at the time a subdivision or development is proposed including any man-made alterations such as grading, excavation or filling which may have occurred prior to the time such subdivision or development is submitted. No land intended for subdivision or development may be regraded or filled in such manner as to circumvent this bylaw. Provisions: The provisions of this Subsection 8.10 shall not apply to building lots in a definitive subdivision plan submitted in accordance with A'iWIgST: A True Copy Town Ole~l~ Co do M.G.L. Chapter 41 in order to obtain the protections afforded by M.G.L. Chapter 40A, Section 6. In addition, the provisions of this Subsection 8.10 shall not apply to building lots in a definitive subdivision plan approved prior to the enactment of this Subsection 8.10. The provisions of this Subsection 8.10 shall not apply to building lots on a plan subject to M.G.L. Chapter 41, Section 81P approved prior to the first date of publication of notice of this bylaw. Defining theSlope: The slope of land at any point, stated as a percentage, shall be defined as the change in elevation over a horizontal distance measured perpendicular to the contours divided by the distance over which the change occurs multiplied by 100. The slope of land at any point, may be stated as a ratio (2:1, 3:1, 4:1, etc.). The first number of the ratio indicates the horizontal distance and the second number indicates the vertical rise. Undisturbed Slopes: All natural slopes exceeding 33% (3:1) over a horizontal distance of 30 feet as measured perpendicular to the contour on a tract or parcel of land imended or proposed for subdivision or on a building lot are protected and shall remain undisturbed. Slope Exclusion for Minimum Lot Area Calculation: All areas with natural slopes exceeding 25% (4:1) over a horizontal distance of 40 feet as measured perpendicular to the contour on a tract or parcel of land intended or proposed for subdivision or development, or on a lot intended for building purposes, shall be excluded f~m the calculation of the minimum lot area required for the applicable zoning district. The Planning Board may grant a special pemtit from the provisions of this Section if, in the Board's opinion, the proposal satisfies the purposes of Subsection 8.10. l.a above. A special permit may be considered if accompanied by: i) ii) A geotechnical report prepared by a registered professional civil engineer in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts that recommends methods for slope stabilization. A commitment from the applicant to fund construction inspection services of a geotechnical engineer. Alison Lescarbeau and Others VOTED BY TWO-THIRD VOTE DECLARED BY THE MODERATOR to adopt Article 30 as printed in thc warrant with the following amendment: Amend 8.10 - Lot/Slope Requirements Section e - Slope Exclusion for Minimum Lot Area Calculation: Replace "exceeding 25% (4:1) over a horizontal distance of 40 feet" with "exceeding 33% (3:1) over a horizontal distance of 30 (thirty) feet". Section e. to read: Slope Exclusion for Minimum Lot Area Calculation: All areas with natural slopes exceeding 33% (3:1) over a horizontal distance of 30 feet as measured perpendicular to the contour on a tract or parcel of land intendedor proposed for subdivision or development, or on a lot intended for building purposes, shall be excluded from the calculation of the minimum lot area required for the applicable zoning district. Delete Section f. in its entirety and replace with: f. · The Planning Board may grant a special permit for exemption from the provisions of this Section if, in the Board's opinion, the proposal satisfies the purposes of Subsection 8.10.1.a above. In cases where the proposal includes disturbing or creating slopes exceeding 33%, the request for special permit must be accompanied by: O A geotechnical report prepared by a registered professional civil engineer in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts that recommends methods for slope stabilization. iii) A commitment from the applicant to fund construction inspection services of a geotechnical engineer. BY ORDER OF ATTORNEY GENERAL APPROVAL CASE #1687 DISAPPROVAL 2 OF 2 SECTION 8.10 LOT SLOPE REQUIREMENTS OF THE ZONING BYLAW FOR THE TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER IS HEREBY ADOPTED AS FOLLOWS: Article 30. Adopt Section 8.10 - Lot/Slope Requirements. To see if the Town will vote to amend the North Andover Zoning Bylaw by adopting Section 8.10 ~ Lot/Slope Requirements, to read as follows: 8.10 - Lot/Slope Requirements "1. Lot/Slope Requirements: In the residential provisions of this Section 8.10 shall apply: a. zoning districts the following Purpose: The purpose of this bylaw is to preserve and enhance the landscape by encouraging the maximum retention of natural topographic features, such as drainage swales, streams, slopes, ridge lines, rock outcroppings, vistas, natural plant fo,nations and trees; to minimize water runoff and soil-erosion problems incurred in grading of steep slopes; to encourage innovative architectural, landscaping, circulation and site design. For the purposes of this subsection, the term "natural" shall be defined as the condition of the ground surface as it exists at the time a subdivision or development is proposed including any man-made alterations such as grading, excavation or filling which may have occurred prior to the time such subdivision or development is submitted. No land intended for subdivision or development may be regraded or filled in such manner as to circumvent this bylaw. Provisions: The provisions of this Subsection 8.10 shall not apply to building lots in a definitive subdivision plan submitted in accordance with M.G.L. Chapter 41 in order to obtain the protections afforded by M.G.L. Chapter 40A, Section 6. (See Disapproval 2 of 2 Case #1687 Attorney General dated September 18, 2001) go Defining the Slope: The slope of land at any point, stated as a percentage, shall be defined as the change in elevation over a horizontal distance measured perpendicular to the contours divided by the distance over which the change occurs multiplied by I00. The slope of land at any point, may be stated as a ratio (2:1, 3:1, 4:1, etc.). The first number of the ratio indicates the horizontal distance and the second number indicates the vertical rise. Undisturbed Slopes: All natural slopes exceeding 33% (3:1) over a horizontal distance of 30 feet as measured perpendicular to the contour on a tract or parcel of land intended or proposed for subdivision or on a building lot are protected and shall remain undisturbed. Slope Exclusion for Minimum Lot Area Calculation: All areas with natural slopes exceeding 25% (4:1) over a horizontal distance of 40 feet as measured perpendicular to the contour on a tract or parcel of land intended or proposed for subdivision or development, or on a lot intended for building purposes, shall be excluded from the calculation of the minimum lot area required for the applicable zoning district. The Planning Board may grant a special permit from the provisions of this Section if, in the Board's opinion, the proposal satisfies the purposes of Subsection 8.10.1.a above. A special permit may be considered if accompanied by: iv) v) A geotechnical report prepared by a registered professional civil engineer in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts that recommends methods for slope stabilization. A commitment from the applicant to fund construction inspection services of a geotechnical engineer.