Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMiscellaneous - 56 BEVERLY STREET Zoning Bylaw Denial Town Of North Andover Building Department 400 Osgood St. North Andover, MA. 01845 Phone 978-688-9545 Fax 978-688-9542 Street: 156 Beverly Street Ma ILot: 9133 A lidant: Steven Derocher Request: Existing garage to be razed/construct new garage Date: I Aril 3, 2015 Please be advised that after review of your Application and Plans that your Application is DENIED for the following Zoning Bylaw reasons: Zoning R-4 Item Notes Item Notes A I Lot Area F Frontage 1 I Lot area Insufficient X 1 Frontage Insufficient 2 1 Lot Area Preexisting X 2 Frontage Complies 3 1 Lot Area Complies 3 Preexisting frontage X 4 1 Insufficient Information 4 Insufficient Information B Use 5 No access over Frontage 1 Allowed X G Contiguous Building Area 2 Not Allowed 1 I Insufficient Area 3 Use Preexisting 2 1 Complies X 4 Special Permit Required X 3 Preexisting CBA 5 Insufficient Information 4 Insufficient information C Setback H Building Height 1 All setbacks comply 1 Height Exceeds Maximum 2 Front Insufficient 2 Complies X 3 Left Side Insufficient X 3 PreexistingHeight 4 Right Side Insufficient X 4 Insufficient Information 5 Rear Insufficient X I Building Coverage 6 Preexistingsetbacks X 1 Coverage exceeds maximum 7 Insufficient Information 2 Coverage Comlies D Watershed 3 Coverage Preexisting X 1 Not in Watershed X 4 Insufficient Information 2 In Watershed J Sign 3 Lot prior to 10/24/94 1 Sign not allowed 4 Zone to be Determined 2 Sign Complies N/A 5 Insufficient Information 3 Insufficient Information E Historic District K Parking 1 In District review required 1 More Parking Required 2 Not in district X 2 Parking Complies X 3 Insufficient Information 1 3 1 Insufficient Information 4 1 Pre-existing Parkin Remedy for the above is checked below. Item# Special Permits Planning Board Item# Variance Site Plan Review Special Permit X Setback Variance(sides&rear) Access other than Frontage Special Permit Parking Variance Frontage Exception Lot Special Permit Lot Area Variance Common Driveway Special Permit Height Variance Congregate Housina Special Permit Variance for Sion Continuing Care Retirement Special Permit X Special Permits Zoning Board Independent Elderly Housing Special Permit Special Permit Non-Confdrming Use ZBA Large Estate Condo Special Permit Earth Removal Special Pern6ZBA Planned Develo meat District S ecial Permit SedPertmit Use nol Listed but Similar Planned Residential S tial Permit 5 ecial Permit for Sign R-6 Density Special Permit Special Permit pre-existing nonconfornin i- Town of North Andover ttECEIVD ZONING BOARD OF APPEAI S®WH ECC . OFFICE Albert P.Manzi III,Esq.Chalmraa ssoarh Ell.P.Mdntyre,via-Clraan as °I • •' ;•.''0 3815 MAY 19 AM 91 16 Richard J.Byers,Esq.Cork Fi •','`. - °`p D.pad Koch Jr. All..Cnada + . + TOWN OF A.w,Mmrberr `' ``� NORTH ANDOVER Michael P.Upnau "'+ '^^^'Ct' MASSACHUSETTS Doug Ludgin s�crass Deney Morgan" I.Md,Time Stump Any appeal shall be filed within(20) Notice of Decision days after the date of filing of this Year 2015 notice in the office of the Town Cled:, er Mass.Gen.L.ch.40A, 17 property at 56 seven Street Ma 9,Parts 33 North Andover,MA 01845 NAME: Steven and Patricia Derochm I HEARING(S): 12 May 2015 ADDRESS: 56 Beverly Street(Map 9,Parcel 33) PETITION: 2015-002A North Andover,MA 01845 The North Andover Board of Appeals held a public hewing at the Town Hall,at 120 Main Street,North Andover, MA on Tuesday,May 12,2015 ar 7:30 PM on the application of Steven and Patricia Derocher for property located at 56 Beverly Street(Map 9,Parcel 33),North Andover,MA 01845. Petitioner is requesting a Special Permit from Section 9.1 of the Zoning By-laws for a pre-existing non-conforming structure or uses however may be extended or altered and also Variances from Table 2(Dimensional Requirements)for one rear yard setback and two side setbacks(left and right)in the R-4 Zoning District,to raze the old garage and construct a new garage. Legal notices were sent In all the certified abutters provided by the Town ofNorth Andover,Assessors Office,and were published in the Eagle-Tribune,a newspaper of general circulation in the Town ofNotth Andover,on April 28, 2015 and May 5,2015. The following regular voting members were present:Albert P.Manzi 111,Ellen McIntyre,Richard J.Byers,D.Paul Koch Jr.,and Allan Cuscia and Associate Member Deney Morganthal. Byers made a motion to Grant the Special Permit from Section 9.1 of the Zoning Bylaw for a pre-existing non- conforming structure or uses however may be extended or altered at 56 Beverly Street(Map 9,Parcel 33),to allow construction for a new garage and to mze the old garage. Cuscia second the motion All in favor to Grant the Special Permit:Albert P.Manzi III,Richard J.Byers,D.Paul Koch Jr.,and Allan Cuscia, Not in favor:Ellen McIntyre 4-1 approved. The Board finds that this use, as developed by the building and site plans, will not adversely affect the neighborhood. There will be no nuisance or serious hazard in vehicles or pedestrians, since there is provisions for the required off-street parking. Adequate and appropriate facilities are provided to the existing residential dwelling and will be provided for the proper continued operation of the newly constructed garage. The Board finds that this garage will not be substantially more detrimental, and that this use, to allow for the proposed garage is in harmony with the general purpose and intent of this Bylaw. 0 Page 1 of2 Site: 56 Beverly Road(Map 9,Parccl 33),North Andover,MA 01845 Petitioner is requesting a Special Permit from Section 9.1 for a pre-existing non-conforming structure and Variances From Table 2 (Dimensional Requirements)for a rear setback and two side setbacks(left and right), located in the R-4 Zonin District to raze and construct a new ars e. Plants)Title: 1)"Plan of the Land"containing one(1)sheet.Exiting&proposed, Prepared by Sullivan Engineering Group,LLC,22 Mount Vernon Road Boxford,MA 01921 Dated January 8,2015 2)"Proposed Rear Elevation"(Containing one sheet),"Proposed Front Elevation"(Containing one sheet),"Proposed 3-D front elevation"(Containing one sheet), 3)Truss details,E-I(Conwining one sheet), Elevations and End Wall Column, and E-2 includes a Front Endwall Elevation,Right Sidewall Elevation,Rest Endwall Elevation,LeftSidewall Elevation and Endwall Column,(Containing one sheet), Prepared by Stephen P.Madan&CO,Engineers/Designers 8011 Paco . rate 201 Kansas City,MO 64131,Dated March 17,2015 Voda in favor: 4 Manzi,Byers,Cuscia,and Koch Voti in the Ne tive: 1 McIntyre The Board finds that the applicant has satisfied the provisions from Section 9.1 for a pre-existing non-conforming structure and Table 2(Dimensional Requirements)for a rear yard setback and two side setbacks (left and right) of the Zoning Bylaws in the R-0 Zoning District to construct a new garage at the location of 56 Beverly Street(Map 9, Parce133),North Andover,MA 01845. Notes: 1. This decision shall not be in effect until a copy ofthis decision is recorded m the Essex County Registry of Mods,Nonhem District at rhe applicant's expense. 2. The granting ofthe Special Permit as requested by the applicant does not necessarily ensure the gaming ofa building rental as the applicant must abide by all applicable local,state,and fedetl building codes and regulations,priorto the issuance of a building permit as required by the haspeclor of Buildings. 3. If the tights authorized by the Special Permit are not exercised within two(2)years of the data of the gran,it shall lapse,and any be re- established only after notice,and a new hearing. No Andover Zonin oard of Appeals AI rt P.Manzi III,Esq.,Chairman A21 McIntyre,Vice Chairman Richard J. Byers,Esq.,Clerk D.Paul Koch Jr.Esq. Allan Cuscia Decision 2015-002A Page 2 of 2 45 `V' LS V' IS NORTH BUILDING PERMIT D TOWN OF NORTH ANDOVER APPLICATION FOR PLAN EXAl I ppq Permit No#: __ Date Received BOARD OF APPEALS ,Ss c US�t Date Issued. IMPORTANT: Applicant must complcte all items on this page LOCATION SG /`SEVER LY 5'Tk EET � Print PROPERTY OWNER 5T6 YEN *' PATRICIA A .SER OCHER - Print 100 Structure yes MAP PAR CEG DI d� STRICT Historic District yes rho L;t/_.:/..J ...:ZON .IMachine Shop village yes <na� TYPE OF IMPROVEMENT PROPOSED USE Residential Non- Residential pt New Building D One family ❑Addition D Two or more family D Industrial D Alteration No. of units: - ❑ Commercial- 5r Repair, replaii3ement ommercial5rRepair, replacement DiAssessoryBldg GARAGE D Others: D Demolition D Other 0`N/atershed District DESCRIPTION OF WORK TO BE PERFORMED: TE 142 DOW At PIr/LREA/T e,A(Zr1GP STRUG'N>Qc AND j`3utL -D New GARAGE Identification- PleaseType or Print Clearly- ,ee 7711 .'21$-,5x78 OWNER: Name: STEVEIv 3 * PAT21e1ra p TFPQr-HcR Phone /J) 978-.zs8-.2 77 Address: 6-6 16yeRI- STREET NORTH AA1P6VE2 MA Contractor Name: Phone: Address: Supervisor's Construction License: Exp. Date: aorrUe„Improvemeflt„License; _ Exp-, Date; ., ARCHITECT/ENGINEER Phone: Address: Reg. No. FEE SCHEDULE;BULGING PERMIT:512.00 PER$1000.00 OF THE TOTAL ESTIMATED COSTBASED ON$125.00 PER S.F. Total Project Cost: $ 5-0,000 FEE: $ Check No.: Receipt No.: NOTE: Persons contracting with unregistered contractors do not have access to the guarantyfund Signature of Agent/Owner Signature of contractor a LO N WA�yy Jia r . 4. y a p[p t f to 111 E y 1 R (f t �� I tr A� �� µ�� � 4q 1 .�� a 4 ♦p♦p♦pjjj � � Rrt 1, _bi e r lY& ra I e I CZ 0 8'' 1� P NT i. LO NAtr 7Q, 7 .aim• -- cu 1�r _ vXv (.b�R Nwnp RoLLaP RoLLUP FFIA !'�ao2 �Ei X /7 9ao2 _30 ,NCM Dad e( PROPOSED FRONT ELEVATION 56 BEVERLY ST. 1 �N_ � cT ° o e ♦ Gp NCR erF " o r e ° • a > s o a PROPOSED READ ELEVATION 56 BEVERLY ST w _ FT r r J i PROPOSED 56 BEVERLY 5T, abuparro AENrtr! 1 9utMYp wµ ( ) cwuenzpon ( ) zwre t ) REOINN9IENT 4GLaYa,Saom m u Wpar a�ax mnn pre pexoonn, pM 6mmllx gkzkm ny gtle u pmhe ray,anC a W Imn m awuen vlxF m nv4Mlaxe NM npgsrlrlpy Mue yeptimnealRy ane rermlappFrape m IaI.MMpuYNgM Wer by Meq svJi onvia butelin anatlwuhdwrm.tlre p'ann p w.M a m.ahr v a+r..d ti q.aicWn M e..r wmre do e,run. sae)ecr PrmM.: MAP PARCEL Name Address 9 33 Steven Demcher 56 Beverly Street North Andover,MA 01845 AbutMrs Proberdes Map Pa Alone, Address 5 2 Robert San Antonio 65 Beverly Street North Andover,MA 0184.5 5 4 0001 Joseph(Javan Cronin 81 Beverly Street North Andover,MA 01845 5 40002 Card Murphy 79 Beverly Street North Andover.MA 01845 5 4-0003 Timothy Ealman 77 Beverly Street North Andover,MA 01845 5 4-0004 Job Seng Gui 7511everly Street North Andover,MA 01845 5 5 John McCaman 75 Sterling Lane North Andover,MA 01845 5 55-0083 Cusack Family Trust 83 Beverly Street North Andover,MA 01845 5 55 0085 Thomas Kendrew 85 Beverly Street Nadh A over,MA 01845 B 12 Barbara King 46 Marblehead Street Nbdh Andover,MA 01845 8 13-0OW Harry Webster 50 Marblehead Street NOM Andover,MA °1845 8 13-0052 Bruce Siemering 52 Marblehead Street Nath Andover,MA 01845 8 14 Romaine Giampss0 60 Marblehead Street North Andover,MA 01845 8 15 Kathleen B Alexander Schnuck 59 Marblehead Street North Andover,MA 01845 8 16 D.L.Resbvo 22 Locke Road Chelmsford,MA 01824 8 17 Paul Murphy 55 Marblehead Street North Andover,MA 01845 8 18 Peter Mamw 9 Spruce Circle Andover,MA 01810 8 19 Janet Lees 47 Marblehead Street North Andover,MA 01845 8 20 Stephen Smith 43 Marblehead Sheet North Andover,MA 018/5 8 21 James Gary Yule 41 Marblehead Street North Andover,MA 01845 8 22 John MrAlcon 37 Marblehead Street NOM Andover,MA 01845 8 37 Janet Lees 47 Marblehead Shaet Nand Andover,MA 01845 8 w John Matheson W Beverly Street NOM Andover,MA 01845 9 1 Arthur McCue 119 OM Essex Road Manchester,MA 01944 9 7 Janey Bandle 69 Union Street NOM Andover,MA 01815 9 27 Alexander Moody 65 Marblehead Street Norm Andover,MA 01845 9 28 John Matheson 79 Marblehead Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 29 Wang,CrbssfielC 93 Union Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 30 Francis Hayes 101 Union Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 31 Owma Noureddine 68 Beverly Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 32 Robert Huard 58 Beverly Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 34 Kizzella Hernandez 100 Union Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 36 Concede Mikols 92 Union Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 37 Edward Snell W Union Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 38 W Riam Callahan 84 Union Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 39 Paul Dubois 57 Second Street North Andover,MA 01845 9 64 Joseph T.Robert 104 Union Street NOM Andover,MA 01845 9 71 Bergstrom,Daniel 71 Marblehead Street North Andover.MA 01845 9 75 Russell Manning 68 Marblehead Street North Andover,MA OIM 9 78 Phaedra Caoshe 87-89 Union Street North Andover,MA 01845 This oertz:: "_3r the names eppeeft on the °Y1e eEY2014 Ase t N records °' Assessors otftce as of This certifies that the names appearing on the �pypr f c3ol3 Date-2 records of the As essors lre as of Ct3rdfied by: _ _ �_. Cerfi ied by: BK 8712 PG 247 Deed 1,Andrew Ngen C. Thu, a/k/a Andrew N.Thu of North Andover, Mesesachuscna in consideration of Two Hundred Sevonty-Two Thousand and 00/100 Dollars(5272,000.00) grant to Steven B. Denwher and Patricia A. Derocher , Bueband and Wife as Terecta by the gntirety of 56 Beverly Street,North Andover, Maesechadem.01845 with quitclaim eoveaeals The itand MM the buddbras thereon reason In North Andover,bounded anal deserlbed as fellow¢: Beginning at a point In the wealerly tire of Be arly Streel one hundred fifty feet earth of Me hard,une of 6eion street L^ at the southwest corner of 12M now or remarry of sae hown font thee.a at abunt light segln easterly by said festooning one hundred.1ne ydhrae and 5110 feet to land new or formerly of George Morton;thence somberly at 1_ sw ur stall,angles forty-wvcn feet he e point; thence westerly at about right angles one hundred nlnely-four feel a N Beverly$met;and theses at shout right angles southerly by aid easterly lion of Beverly Street fifty feet to she result or beglonial. �Q Containing 9,299 ar aus feet more or leas,and being Lot Na t and part of Let No.2 en "Plan of Land owned by Checks G.Gtea.is,Nord,"court,M..,February 191211,which Plan is connected ire the Baa s arlh District Registry Of Deeds as Plan No.0561. Being the..faced.,tomeyed by restaurant V.The and Mean Truaeg dated February 28,20M aadihowdecowth St he Ever Needs Ubtalel gallery of Used,al Book 6029,Page the. g J i N 1^ .1 y O N t9 T p O O. es,— Executed sera sealed instrument this 20th day of Avail, 2004. ( S d a 'Yl 4-20-A Andrew Ng" C. Thu Commonwealth of Massachusetts Baeex, an: M chip 20th they of April, 2004, before was, thou undersigned notary public, peracoally appeared ABdree Hgen C. Thu ptovad to me through aatiefaetory evidence of identification, which wane hie liceaae t, to be the person whose name is signed on the preeding or attached document,and acknowledged to me that he sighed it voluntarily for its stated purpose. ,. IdPIBIQigM/ BBrMYNBB Oh4111WW11i1�iY11� ...... ................ _._. __.__-(Sea0 Steven B. &Patricia A. DeRocher 56 Beverly Street, North Andover, MA Home (978)258-2779—cell (774)218-5078 Purpose: Letter supporting request for variance &/or special permit due to the property shape (hardship). The lot is undersized(9,385 sq.ft.)for the R-4 zoning district.(12,500 sq.ft. required)and the 50 foot lot width is restrictive. Project: Raze existing nonconforming garage and construct new less non-conforming garage A) When the survey of the property was completed it was found that the existing non-conforming structure is actually encroaching 1.3 feet onto property at 58 Beverly Street. B) Due to the location of the proposed garage we are requesting a variance &/or special permit. The new garage will be less non-conforming to current R4 zoning setback requirements. .Background: 1) The existing 85 year old structure is encroaching on property at 58 Beverly Street and in need of repair / replacement 2) The existing rear wall is a concrete block retaining wall that is failing & cracked due to tree roots pushing the wall forward. A) Movement of the rear concrete block wall has also caused the front wall to bow B) The shed type"flat"roof is weakened&leaking Q The concrete floor is damaged & cracking due to water leakage (freezing & thawing) through the rear wall and from the roof. 3) We have safety concerns regarding "snow load" and the rear of the existing garage roof is three feet above ground level where people or animals might climb onto the roof. Plan: 11 Reconstruct garage.Move foundation off of 58 Beverly Street property. 2) New construction will have poured concrete retaining walls(three sides).The rear wall is to be located forward three feet from existing. The two side walls will be repositioned so they will be located fully within the property lines of 56 Beverly Street. 3) The new concrete pad (floor elevation) will be one foot lower than current floor to better match the grade of the yard. 4) Proposed front wall,gables&roof are to be of steel construction. Benefits are; Fire: reduced fire hazard on the structure which is located close to neighboring properties. Safety: No easy access for people and animals to climb onto the roof at the rear of the building. Land owners: Steven B. DeRocher Patricia A. DeRocher -"Il'r Town of North Andover ZONING BOARD OF APPFALf RECEIVED Albers P.M—IB,Esq.Cb.r ,. OWN rLERK'S OFFICE Ellen P.Mchi Noarn tyre,ViaLbam�on oe Richard J.Byers,Esq.C&k 3= ••'-` ` �"$� 2015 MAY 19 AM 9: 16 D.Past Koch), Allan Cusps a A. M ba,, ` ::sy. , i� Michael P.L;porro •%'b; ..M• TOWN OF Doug Ludgin 'sa�cwas.�a ACHUSETTS Deney Morganthal Town Clerk Time Scamp Any appeal shall be died within(20) Notice of Decision days after the date of filing of this Year 2015 notice in the office ofthe Town Clerk, er Mass.Gen.L.ch.40A, I7 Pro eh 56 Beverl Sheet Me 9,Parsd 3l North Andover,MA 01845 NAME: Steven and Patricia Derocher HEAMNU(S): 12 May 2015 ADDRESS: 56 Beverly Street(Map 9,Parce133) PETITION: 2015-002B North Andover,MA 01845 The North Andover Board of Appeals held a public hearing at the Town Hall,at 120 Main Street,North Andover, MA on Tuesday,May 12,2015 at 7:30 PM on the application of Steven and Patricia Derocher for property located at 56 Beverly Street(Map 9,Parcel 33),North Andover,MA 01845. Petitioner is requesting a Special Permit from Section 9.1 of the Zoning By-laws for a pre-existing non-conforming structure or uses however may be extended or altered and also Variances from Table 2(Dimensional Requirements)for one rear yard setback and two side setbacks(left and right)in the R4 Zoning District,to raze the old garage and construct a new garage. Legal notices were sent to all the certified abutters provided by the Town of North Andover,Assessors Office,and were published in the Eagle-Tribune,a newspaper of general circulation in the Town of North Andover,on April 28, 2015 and May 5,2015. The following regular voting members were present:Albert P.Manzi BI,Ellen McIntyre,Richard J. Byers,D.Paul Koch Jr,and Allan Cuscia and Associate member Doug Ludgin. Byers made a motion to Grant the Variances from Table 2 of the Zoning Bylaw for 56 Beverly Street(Map 9, Parcel 33),to construct a new garage. The Variances are for one rear yard setback,the proposed is 5.2 feet, required is 30 feet(relief is 24.8 feet),also a left side setback and right side setback are needed,the proposed is I foot,required is 15 feet(relief is 14 feet)in the R4 Zoning District. Cuscia second the motion All in favor to Grant the Variances:Albert P.Manzi III,Richard J.Byers,D.Paul Koch Jr. and Allan Cuscia. Not in favor:McIntyre 4-1 approved The Board finds that owing to circumstances relating to soil conditions, shape, or topography of the land or structures and especially affecting such land or structures,but not affecting generally the zoning district in general,a literal enforcement of the provisions of the Bylaw will involve substantial hardship, financial or otherwise, to the petitioner or applicant. The Board finds that desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent ofthe purpose of this bylaw. The Board also finds that this use, as developed by the building&site plans, is an appropriate location for such a use and will not adversely affect the neighborhood. There will be no nuisance or serious hazard to vehicles or pedestrians,since there are provisions for the required off-street parking. Adequate and appropriate facilities will be provided for the newly proposed garage. The Board finds that the proposed garage will not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood and that this use, is in harmony with the neighborhood and general purpose and intent of this Bylaw. Page 1 oft �'�` Site: 56 Beverly Road(Map 9,Parcel 33),North Andover,MA 01845 Petitioner is requesting a Special Permit from Section 9.1 for a pre-existing nonconforming structure and Variances From Table 2 (Dimensional Requirements)for a rear setback and two side setbacks(left and right), located in the R4 Zonin District to raze and construct a new ora e. Plans)Title: 1)`Plan of the Land"containing one(1)sheet.Exiting&proposed, Prepared by Sullivan Engineering Group,LLC,22 Mount Vernon Road Boxford,MA 01921 Dated January 8,2015 2)"Proposed Rear Elevation"(Containing one sheet),"Proposed Front Elevation"(Containing one sheet),"Proposed 3-D front elevation"(Containing one sheet), 3)Truss details,E-1(Containing one sheet),and Elevations and End Wall Column,E-2 includes a Front Endwall Elevation,Right Sidewall Elevation, Rear Endwall Elevation,LeftSidewall Elevation and Endwall Column, (Containing one sheet), Prepared by Stephen P.Muslin&CO, Engineers/Designers 8011 Paseo Suite 201 Kansas City,MO 64131 Dated March 17,2015 Votin in favor: 4 Manzi,B ers,Cuscia,and Koch VOOM in the Negative : 1 I McIntyre The Board finds that the applicant has satisfied the provisions from Section 9.1 for a pre-existing nonconforming structure and Table 2(Dimensional Requirements) for a rear yard setback and two side setbacks (left and right)of the Zoning Bylaws in the R-4 Zoning District to construct a new garage at the location of 56 Beverly Street(Map 9, Parcel 33),North Andover,MA 01845. Notes: 1, This decision shall not be in effect until a copy of this decision is recorded at the Essex County Registry of Deeds,Northern District at the applicant's expense. 2. The granting of the Variance as requested by the applicant does not necessarily cosmic the granting ofa building permit as the applicant must abide by all applicable local,some,and federal building codes and regulations,prior to the issuance of a building permit az required by the hispector of Buildings. 3. If the rights authmiaed by the Variance are not exercised within one(I)years of the date of Me greet,it shall lapse,and may be re- established only after notice,and a new hearing. North ndover Zoningoard of pYk peals Albe P. Manzi III,Esq.,Chairman Ellen McIntyre,Vice Chairman Richard J. Byers,Esq.,Clerk D.Paul Koch Jr.Esq. Allan Cuscia Decision 2015-000B Page 2 of 2